Yamaha HS5 Vs HS8 | Ultimate Guide 2020

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email

There’s no doubt that Yamaha’s HS5 and HS8 studio monitors are incredibly popular. Many consumers struggle to determine which is better, though, so we’ve carried out extensive research to make your decision easier.

Overall, we’ve found the HS8 to be better. It’s designed for a more professional setup and will upgrade your music. Even so, this doesn’t mean there’s no value in buying the HS5.

The Yamaha HS5 vs HS8 showdown will show what each speaker has to offer.

Yamaha HS5 Vs HS8 | Comparison Review

Yamaha HS5

Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor

Buy on Amazon

Yamaha HS5 | Complete Review

Yamaha is a Japanese multinational, producing various products across many industries, but with an excellent grasp on the music industry.

The HS5 is more suited to small rooms and studios. Its compact nature makes it portable and compatible with small spaces.

Beginners—the relevant customer segment—are unlikely to have large studio spaces, so this product is ideal for them.

Specs

  • Powered: 100 to 240 VAC
  • Power Configuration: 70W (Lower Frequency: 45W, Higher Frequency: 25W)
  • LF Driver Size: 5 inches
  • LF Driver Type: Cone
  • HF Driver Size: 1 inch
  • HF Driver Type: Dome
  • LF Driver Amp: Full-range amplifier
  • Frequency Response: 54Hz to 30kHz 
  • Crossover Frequency: 2kHz 
  • Maximum Peak SPL: 90dB 
  • Input Types: XLR3-31; phone
  • Enclosure Type: Active 2-way
  • Height: 11.25 inches
  • Width: 6.69 inches
  • Depth: 8.75 inches
  • Weight: 12.1 pounds

Pros

  • Accurate sound for the price.
  • Impressive frequency response.
  • Bi-amp design driver for great mid and high frequencies.
  • Room Control feature to optimize sound.

Cons 

  • Performance at bass frequencies is poor. 
  • Compromised performance when placed against a wall.
mixer vs audio interface cartoon letters

Yamaha HS8

YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black

Buy on Amazon

Yamaha HS8 vs JBL LSR308

The Yamaha HS8 is better for professionals while suiting treated sound production rooms.  Those who want to take their music to the next level will enjoy this product. It offers better sound quality: the type that the pros seek.

While Yamaha is usually associated with cheaper products, most people don’t know that it’s adept at making high-end products, with the Yamaha HS8 being a classic example.

The HS8 is more expensive than its counterpart, and the sound quality is great across all frequency ranges. You’ll feel as though you’re seated in a studio when you’re at home. In addition, the woofer produces low distortion and avoids interference.

Specs

  • Powered: 100 to 240 VAC
  • Power Configuration: 120W (Lower Frequency: 75W; Higher Frequency: 45W)
  • LF Driver Size: 8 inches
  • LF Driver Type: Cone
  • HF Driver Size: 1 inch
  • HF Driver Type: Dome
  • LF Driver Amp: Full-range amplifier
  • Frequency Response: 38Hz to 30kHz
  • Crossover Frequency: 2kHz
  • Maximum Peak SPL: 100dB
  • Input Types: XLR3-3; phone
  • Enclosure Type: Active 2-way
  • Height: 15.4 inches
  • Width: 9.8 inches
  • Depth: 13.1 inches
  • Weight: 22.5 pounds

Pros

  • Excellent for professionals.
  • Highly accurate sound.
  • Impressive low-frequency sound.
  • No need for a separate subwoofer. 

Cons

  • About twice as expensive as the HS5.
  • Poor value for beginners.

Yamaha HS5 vs HS8

Face-to-Face

Tech Specs

Overall, the HS8 is our winner tech-wise, but check out our detailed breakdown to explain why…

Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor
YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black
Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor
YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black
$199.99
Price not available
Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor
Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor
$199.99
YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black
YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black
Price not available

Powered

Both speakers are the same in this regard, working with 100 to 240V. This isn’t surprising considering how close the products are, and both being Yamaha monitors.

Winner: Draw

Yamaha HS5 vs HS8

Power Configuration

The HS8 has an impressive power output of 120 Watts. This is responsible for the better sound quality the product has. 

The 120 Watts splits into 75 Watts for the low frequency driver and 45 Watts for the high frequency.

Both drives perform better than those found on the HS5. This means the bass sounds and high pitches sound better on the HS5. The speaker costs two to three times more than HS8, so this performance is no surprise.

The HS5 has a 70 Watt output, distributed as follows: 45 Watts for low frequency and 25 Watts for high frequency. This doesn’t compare well to the HS8, but it’s still better than most speakers at this price range. 

Despite the strong competition offered by its competitor, the HS5 is still a good speaker. 

Winner: HS8

Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor

LF Driver Size

The 8-inch LF driver size in the HS8 ensures the speaker performs well at low frequencies. This gives it its great-sounding bass.

Its counterpart only has a 5-inch LF driver. Consequently, the bass sounds aren’t impressive. You’ll need an additional subwoofer if you purchase the HS5. 

Winner: HS8: The LF driver in the HS5 is smaller and delivers less power. These specifications are no match for our winner.

HF Driver Size 

Both speakers have the same-sized HF driver. This is surprising since the HS8’s HF driver delivers more power and is in a much bigger device, so we’d expect the HF driver to be bigger. 

The driver size is similar to that found on the much smaller and less powerful HS5. Despite this similarity, the HS8’s HF driver sounds better—it offers richer sounds that most professionals would love.

Winner: Draw

best studio monitors for hip hop image

Frequency Response

Yamaha speakers have impressive frequency response—even the lower end ones—which is the case for this Yamaha HS5 vs. HS8 showdown.

Despite the disparity in price, the performance is similar in this regard. It’s hard to beat a frequency response that ranges from 54 Hertz to 30 kiloHertz. 

But, the HS8 has a slight edge over the HS5. It extends its range to include frequencies as low as 30 Hertz. This contributes to the great bass sounds offered by this speaker.

The HS8 has edged its counterpart here. But, the HS5 still has an impressive frequency response that most speakers at its price range will struggle to beat.

Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor

Winner: HS8

Crossover Frequency 

Crossover filters separate a musical input into one or more outputs. They decide which speaker is better, depending on the sound frequency produced. Such components are important in a bi-amp speaker design like that found in the HS5 and HS8. 

A crossover frequency is the frequency that such filters use to determine which output is better. For both monitors, the crossover frequency is 2 kiloHertz. This is quite high compared to other speakers, which means the LF driver performs really well.

Winner: Draw

Maximum SPL Peak 

SPL—sound pressure level—measures how efficient and sensitive a speaker is. Louder speakers have a higher SPL. 

The HS8 has an SPL of 100 decibels, which is over 10% more than HS5’s at 90dB.

Winner: HS8

YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black

Design

Companies are paying more attention to design, and there are serious advantages for doing so. For the consumer, a well-designed monitor adds to the studio’s look and feel, with some customers preferred design over technical features.

The HS8 and HS5 look very similar, which is a running theme of the HS series. At a glance, it’s hard to differentiate between the two, but we can make some comparisons.

Some like the HS5’s practical nature. The edges are straight and have smooth curves on corners. It’s a well-shaped, rectangular box with a tweeter and woofer. There also isn’t a great deal of branding, which is a breath of fresh air. Unbridled consumerism has encouraged companies to put their company logo on everything, but this can be visually exhausting.

A clean, simple design like this makes the product look premium. The natural colors —black, white and silver—are very versatile. This makes them suitable for any desktop setup.

The HS8 doesn’t offer anything different besides its size: it’s a bigger “box.” Many people would expect a product that costs twice as much to have a different design, especially if both products are from the same company. But, that’s not the case. And for those who are value-driven, that’s great news!

Note that the price difference isn’t a matter of using more expensive materials, but more of a reflection on the manufacturing cost. This ensures you’re getting more value for your money since the price is in the technical ability rather than superficial features.

Even so, the HS8 doesn’t aesthetically offer anything above the HS5. So, in terms of design, you get more value from the HS5.

Winner: HS5

YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black

Standout Features

There are no standout features the HS5 has that our winner doesn’t. What the HS8 has over its counterpart is: 

  • 75W LF plus 45W HF bi-amp system: This configuration allows for clear and crisp sound.
  • Ultra-wide frequency range: The 38Hz to 30kHz frequency response is ideal for content creation. It offers versatility for a wide range of multimedia. 

Conclusion

Use the HS8 if you:

  • Are a professional content creator.
  • Need daily accurate and rich sounds. 
  • Have a treated room that functions as a studio. 
  • Have a little more to spend. 
YAMAHA HS8 Studio Monitor, Black
  • 8 inch cone woofer and 1 inch dome tweeter; Produce low distortion sound with a well-defined bottom end at any output level
  • 38Hz to 30kHz frequency response; Power consumption: 60 watts
  • 75W LF plus 45W HF bi amp system 120W total;Level control (+4dB/center click), EQ: High trim switch (+/ 2dB at HF) / Room control switch (0/2/4 dB under 500Hz)
  • Room control and high trim response controls
  • XLR and TRS phone jack inputs. Crossover: 2kHz

Use the HS5 if you: 

  • Need quality on a budget. 
  • Consider yourself a beginner. 
  • Have no interest in music production. 
Sale
Yamaha HS5 Powered Studio Monitor
  • 2-Way bass-reflex bi-amplified nearfield studio monitor with 5" cone woofer and 1" dome tweeter
  • 54Hz-30kHz frequency response
  • 45W LF plus 25W HF bi-amp system for high-performance 70W power amplification
  • Room Control and High TRIM response controls
  • XLR and TRS phone jack inputs accept balanced or unbalanced signals